Here to Help
If you have questions about insurance policies, billing, claims, or just getting started, one of our insurance experts would be happy to assist you. Reach out to us using the contact information below, or send us a message using our online form. We’d love to hear from you.
Contact Hurley Insurance Brokers
Want to chat with us about your insurance options in person? Contact us on your terms.
Hurley Insurance Brokers, Inc.
Text: (412) 682-6100
Phone: (412) 682-6100
Fax: (412) 682-6100
3508 Fifth Ave.
Pittsburgh, PA 15213
*Office hours by appointment only.
Schedule a Call
Get in touch
Prefer that we give you a call? Simply complete the form below and one of our insurance experts will be in touch.
Schedule a Call
Our Accomplishments
Reviews
Social Rating
4.9
Based on 116 reviews
Hurley Insurance Brokers
4.9
Stephen Peat
21:45 05 Jan 22
I mostly deal with Holly, graet service --5 stars
Walter Debo
18:09 05 Jan 22
Very responsive and knowledgable about questions that I had throughout the startup process. Would recommend to anybody.
Judy Cameron
14:33 21 Dec 21
Hurley Insurance Brokers are really a pleasure to work with! They are professional and look into all the options available. Their work is very high quality and they double check everything. And they are extremely responsive and will look into all issues raised by clients carefully. I particularly want to call out Jessica Liebe who is very responsive and keeps the client well informed as things progress.
shanasimmonsdance
13:53 30 Nov 21
Steve Rucker
12:01 10 Nov 21
M-Powerhouse Inc.
21:23 08 Nov 21
I would like to thank Jessica for her professionalism and prompt response to the needs of our organization. Quality work at it's finest. Thank You
James Loughlin
19:12 08 Nov 21
Hurley Insurance Brokers have been my insurance brokers pretty much when I first opened my Business. The staff that I had the pleasure working with Jessica Liebe and Brennon Hurley, have been super helpful in providing me what I need to insure my business. I would recommend Hurley Insurance Brokers to anyone in need of a professional insurance broker that looks out for there clients.
Ed Guernsey
18:06 01 Nov 21
Holly Hamilton is GREAT team member
Nosam Contracting
00:03 20 Oct 21
I've been using Hurley for about 10 years now. They've covered everything for my business and personal needs. Hands down the best experience I've ever had with a broker and I hope we are working together 10 years from now!
Kevin Greenberg
12:58 17 Oct 21
Earl Smithson Jr.
21:31 07 Sep 21
My representative, Holly, was fantastic. Hurley Insurance provided me with quick and professional service. Thank you.
Jennifer Quigley
18:18 31 Aug 21
Beth was incredibly helpful and responsive. She has saved me over $500 annually on my multiple policies.
Niko Nikolopoulos
15:01 26 Aug 21
This was my first time setting up insurance and Holly was extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Would Recommend.
Keith White
18:18 20 Aug 21
Rich Clemons
18:07 20 Aug 21
I contacted Hurley Insurance Brokers and was immediately impressed by their willingness to help and professionalism. They got me a better rate for both of my polices.
Bobby Benson
00:15 04 Aug 21
Every time I need anything Jessica has been on it! Highly recommend!
Jonathon Crudup
17:57 20 Jul 21
Holly has been great to work with. She was responsive and had a great depth of knowledge to answer all of my questions. Highly recommend Holly and Hurley!
Alecia Wenslow
00:37 17 Jul 21
I moved to PA from Maine and felt like everything was going horribly. I reached out to Hurley hoping to make getting car and renters insurance easier. Beth Ladzinski was phenomenal! She was fast and professional. She took all my information, sent me proposal, and was able to answer any questions I had about coverages. She worked to get me the coverages I wanted for the best premium. Beth really helped make tjay aspect of moving less of a headache, I'm so glad I reached out!
Marlena Coumos
18:07 16 Jul 21
Beth was very patient and helpful with us as we condensed all of our policies. It was a pleasure working with her and she helped us understand all of our decisions. Highly recommend Hurley!
Jordyn Gonzales / Brown
15:13 16 Jul 21
Eric Kush Sr.
19:53 13 Jul 21
Have been working with Beth Ladzinski, awesome person, so attentive to our family’s needs, always easy to reach, super responsive
Eric K.
12:49 13 Jul 21
Beth Ladzinski is awesome, always looking out for our family, very attentive, always easy to reach, we may be her only client at least that's how it seems
natalie black
02:36 13 Jul 21
recently had an accident which is making me so sad, but Holly was so helpful in reaching out to me to make sure everything was going okay and checking if i had questions on anything. i don’t think i’d be nearly as collected if it wasn’t for her
Eric K.
21:30 20 Jun 21
Beth,always has our best interest at heart, diligently looking out for usEric K
andrew warwick
14:35 19 Jun 21
Brennan and his team were able to find the best policy for us and took the time to explain everything we needed and were getting in our policy. Working with him to get home insurance was by far the easiest part of the buying process.
Daija Berry
16:03 10 Jun 21
Awesome and super fast got me a low monthly quote and extremely friendly!
Keila and Ryan Gorman
18:08 08 Jun 21
You’d have trouble finding better people to work with when it comes to insurance.
Nash Oudit
15:24 08 Jun 21
Jessica and Brennan are a great team. Extremely professional and honest. I highly recommend.
Teresa Alexander
13:08 08 Jun 21
Holly Hamilton was very efficient in getting us homeowners insurance fast. The whole process was easy and Holly kept in contact throughout the whole process. Thank you for helping us get homeowners fast and easy.
Tanya Diehl
22:07 07 May 21
david smith
13:34 04 May 21
I have always been treated with respect and professionalism by Hurley Insurance Brokers. They prioritize what is best for their clientele above all else and it is very much Appreciated !
Matt Delletro
16:02 03 May 21
Ed Guernsey
23:26 16 Apr 21
Holly is a great person and was so helpful in explaining our new policies clearly and in terms we were able to understand. We love Holly and could not be happier. Thank you so much Holly, not only for working with us but, for providing us so much peace of mind as well.Sincerely Ed and Michele
Desiree Walker
10:30 12 Apr 21
Brennan and Kelsey Hurley have always been patient, kind, and have always made sure my insurance needs were taken care of. I'm a very satisfied, long term client!
Wendell Dixon
19:37 09 Apr 21
Stephanie Heisler
20:56 18 Mar 21
Hands down amazing customer service. Beth Ladzinski absolutely fantastic. She answered every single question I came up with and followed up with me to see if I had any additional questions that needed to be answered.I am not someone who likes to make changes often and when it comes down to comparing policies She made the process very easy.Beth is very professional and kind. If you need insurance I would highly recommend giving her a call.
Mike Harsh
18:27 17 Mar 21
Elissa McCarty
01:09 17 Mar 21
Brennan and his team are amazing. There are always there when I need them. They always take time to answer my questions and to guide me in the insurance process. They are professional and they are always checking to make sure that our company has the coverage we need.
Jason Burns
01:06 12 Mar 21
Thank you Jessica Liebe for helping me with my commercial insurance needs and questions. I'm always happy to refer you to my family and friends for any type of their insurance needs.
john spavelko
16:17 05 Mar 21
I HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH HURLEY INSURANCE FOR YEARS AND HAVE ALWAYS RECEIVED EXCELLENT. I'VE RECENTLY WORKES WITH Holly Hamilton AND SHE'S BEEN DOING GREAT WORK! JOHN S.
Steven Goetz
00:07 15 Feb 21
Jessica L. is wonderful!
Brenda Schley
00:41 10 Feb 21
Exurbia Home Health
21:27 15 Jan 21
Brennan was the start of my experience and he is extremely helpful! Then I spoke with Joan and she retired CATCH 22!! I am optimistic they have other great agents!! They reallly will do anything and everything to make you happy!-Sheila
Eric Shaw
23:21 25 Dec 20
Excellent company, great rates, fantastic customer service.
Tom Gallagher
01:59 12 Dec 20
Shequil Robertson
10:53 15 Nov 20
John Wicker
19:29 09 Nov 20
Chelse Schrecengost
20:43 21 Oct 20
We have worked with Brennan multiple times, and each has been outstanding service that he provides, which is why we keep coming back when needed.He is calm, with a soft voice, and will walk you through any necessary steps needed to fulfill whatever contract necessary. This company is amazing and I would NOT recommend anyone else.
Steve Kopy
03:19 16 Oct 20
Jessica was great. Responded quickly to my questions and took the time to help me complete neccessary forms.
Paula Rothrauff
21:11 12 Oct 20
I highly recommend Hurley Insurance Brokers for their professionalism, top quality agents, responsiveness, great rates and friendliness. We have been insured with Hurley Insurance since 2013 for both small business and personal insurances. It was the best decision ever made. Over the years, Brennan, Kelsey, Karley, and Jessica have been phenomenal! These are truly the nicest, hardest working people you want to know and who you want in your corner. Hands down, the BEST customer service. I cannot say enough nice things about them, and the way they run their business cannot say enough about who they are. Call them. Today. You will be glad you did!
Niko Cheronis
21:50 09 Oct 20
Very helpful and great experience. Recommend to others
Joe Brown
23:22 14 Jul 20
I have been using Hurley Insurance Brokers for several years now. I continue to use them, because they provide me with superior customer service. They provide me with heads up on new products and opportunities that could prove to be a benefit to me and my business. The leave the decisions to me and never try to apply any pressure. I trust them implicitly.
A P.
14:50 13 Apr 20
Brennan was very helpful and had a quick turn-around for the quote. I appreciate that he looked at the whole picture for our business insurance needs and...
Chris R.
10:26 19 Mar 20
These people are completely amazing and great we called and within 15 minutes has renter's insurance no time at all.
Crystal W.
06:19 14 Jan 20
I'm all about customer service. I have worked retail (in the past) and in customer service over a decade now and consumers truly rely on word of mouth and...
Michelle Balfe
23:34 14 Nov 19
Joan has been great! She is professional, patients, and easy to work with. Looking forward to working with and Hurley
Tessa M.
11:35 27 Aug 19
I had a really complicated situation to try to take care of, and Hurley Insurance Brokers really helped me out. They were personable, quick to respond, and...
Pam Kuzma Jones
22:54 26 Aug 19
I’ve been with Hurley Insurance Brokers for several years now and highly recommend them! They are always helpful and easy to contact! Every time I had a question they were always there to help!! Wouldn’t use anyone else!!
Eric Kush Sr.
04:13 01 Aug 19
Joan batson is awesome, she has taken great care of our whole family house, multiple cars, always responsive courteous
Angel Botti
12:38 15 Jun 19
Brennan and his staff worked great to find the best rates and did it in a quick and timely manner. I look forward to building business relationships with him and his team!!!
Oksana C.
08:14 28 May 19
I am so glad I found this company! Brennan has been wonderful in leading me through the process of obtaining insurance for a property in Pittsburgh....
Kerri Sarsfield
18:26 10 Aug 18
Just finished working with Joan. It was an easy process and she saved us money while increasing our benefits!
Mike McGroarty Jr.
16:22 05 Jun 18
The whole team at Hurley Insurance does a great job. They're very responsive and professional.
Paula Rothrauff Benson
16:28 25 Aug 17
We are so thankful for Hurley Insurance Brokers! They are the BEST company to work with. Prompt, courteous, professional, knowledgeable, friendly, and understanding are only a few ways to describe them. Brennan and Jessica have been wonderful to work with. Any questions or needs that we have are always met with a no-hassle, can do attitude and always attention to detail. The sense of security that we feel knowing that our interests are being protected by the Hurley Insurance Brokers is priceless. Thank you all for the hard work you do! We look forward to many more years of a great working relationship! Paula Benson, Office Manager, AquaGuard Systems, Inc.
Dana Humphries
22:01 07 Aug 17
My husband and I worked with Jessica to obtain homeowners insurance for our very first home. She took what was, to us, another possibly terrifying experience, and made it simple! I can't tell you what a relief it was to have such a pleasant, easy experience. I'd recommend Hurley, and Jessica to anyone!
Brian McCollum
20:57 01 Aug 17
Year one, 5 stars but I feel like after starting a successful engagement with Brendan, he doesn't handle renewals. Renewals 3 stars. The questionnaire feels like "how many more ways can we find to raise your premium"
Bobby Benson
21:41 18 May 17
Ask for Brennan, he was very prompt and had me insured with one phone call. Hands down best customer service.
Kristine Masta
18:37 07 May 17
I am pleased to recommend Kelsey Hurley and Hurley Insurance Brokers. They were a pleasure to work with. Timely in their response, professional, explained everything clearly, canceled the former policies and made everything a breeze! Thank you so much Kelesy!
Kristine M.
11:35 07 May 17
I am pleased to recommend Kelsey Hurley and Hurley Insurance Brokers. They were a pleasure to work with. Timely in their response, professional, explained...
Nina Marie Barbuto
18:33 20 Apr 17
Brennan Hurley has been the best to work with. He and his associates have been very responsive to all our requests at Assemble. Assemble, a non-profit, educational, community Makerspace and Gallery, does not fit easily into any boxes on any forms. Brennan has patiently helped us to find what we need as well as explain it to us so we can understand. He he has been wonderful with all of my questions. I ask a lot of questions.
Trevor Kurtz
01:45 19 Dec 16
My company recently signed up for general contracting insurance with Hurley Insurance Brokers. We attempted to go through three other insurance companies, but communication was always slow and questions went unanswered. Hurley Insurance Brokers was the exact opposite. Our agent Brennan was able to answer all questions asked, provided us with a package that was appropriate for our level of business, and assured us that increasing our insurance with them as our business grew would be very easy. If you want a knowledgeable staff, quick communication, and an uncomplicated process, go with Hurley Insurance Brokers.
Greg Walko
18:25 08 Mar 16
When you write a review about today's marketplace, whether brokers. retail stores, restaurants, you usually have to grade on a curve to give a 5 star review. But Hurley Brokers are a throwback to a time when agents came to your house, knew your name (maybe your kids' names), took time and researched what best fit your needs, and your budget, and were there every time you called.In the last eight months, Brennan saved us a good deal of money when he dug deep and found a great price on specialty coverage I didn't want, but was forced to buy. Before that he beaten the already good price from my previous insurer for the year's coverage, and throughout when I had questions, he responded every single time I emailed...within minutes.His sharp assistant Kelsey phoned twice today to remind that my policy would expire tomorrow, March 9.This is 5 Star+ across the board service on anyone's list, in any time, present or past. And I'm not sure he wouldn't come to the house if he had to.Greg Walko
Tom S.
11:42 24 Jun 13
Bennan was super helpful when I was shopping for homeowner and auto insurance. He provided me with a quote that was competitive and comprehensive, while...
Free W.
12:13 10 Aug 12
I've always hated shopping for insurance. The whole process of getting quotes from different agencies always just pissed me off, and when I was done I...
Jen A.
11:36 08 Aug 12
Hurley Ins Brokers were able to find me an insurance package that was of high value at a low cost to cover my home and auto. I came from having USAA, which...
Clickable Coverage
